Spread the wealth doesn’t work: Why socialism is a failure

Pat Lenconi, writing at The Simple Wisdom Project, answers the question “What’s so bad about socialism?” especially in light of the fact that the Bible points to ideals like caring for one another , sharing with those in need and avoiding materialism. I think his answer is helpful:

I must admit that, as a youngster, I often wondered why people were so down on socialism, and its cousin, communism. In fact, I thought those sounded like the best ways to run a society because sharing and caring and compassion are the right ways to live.

As I became a young adult, I began to understand how the reality of socialism radically differs from the theory, and that even the theory itself has fatal flaws. When it comes right down to it, I think there are two big reasons why socialism is a really, really bad idea.

First, it just doesn’t work. At least not for very long. That’s because people are flawed and, outside of a family, a religious order, or a small group of friends, they will not continually work hard for the ‘greater good’ if they do not receive the fruits of that work themselves. As an economics major in college, I learned that this theory had a name: ‘the free-loader effect’. It is the natural tendency of people to do less and less work when they realize that they won’t see a proportionate decrease in what they can get for it.

Over time—and this is an inevitable consequence of the free-loader effect—socialist societies experience decreasing productivity, risk-taking, and innovation, along with increasing tax rates, promises of government programs, and expectations from citizens about what they can get from those programs. When the economy inevitably falters under its own weight, those expectations cannot be met.

Unfortunately, by the time enough citizens realize this is happening it is often too late for them to go back and try a different approach because there are more people in society who expect benefits from the government than there are people who pay for them. And thus begins the long, gradual descent to economic and motivational malaise. Ironically, the class of people who socialism is supposed to help—the poor—only grows because they are joined by more and more people who drop out of the shrinking middle class.

Go here to read the rest of his article.


HT: Matt Perman

One thought on “Spread the wealth doesn’t work: Why socialism is a failure

  1. You know, without the word “Socialism”, Christians who believe Free Market Captialism is the Savior of the present world would really have nothing to do.

    Is President Obama the perfect leader for this country at this present time? Probably not, but he is a heck of a lot better than the leadership previously; but I digress.

    I suppose a better question would be, “Was Jesus a Free Market Captialist?” The obvious and correct answer is a resounding NO! However, we live in a country were Christians are more political than biblical and it is often OK for someone to loose their health, house and living because they weren’t “like us” or they didn’t hold the correct core spiritual or political beliefs.

    Let me ask you this: If YOU were loosing your house and a government program was the only means by which to save your home for your family, would YOU turn down the program? Just as there are no atheist in fox holes, there is a socialist just under the surface of captialist down on his luck.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s